Saturday, 26 December 2009

Unseasonal Snow

For those snowy parts of Britain suffering this week, it’s rather ironic that on the one day we look forward to snow—Christmas Day—none was generally forecast. Yet, this week, snow and frost have been significant factors in messing things up, even down to the possible post-Christmas arrival of internet ordered Christmas gifts and fare. Santa is not pleased.

We “enjoyed” heavy snow last February. Then, we argued that the best time for a heavy, sustained snowfall was indeed late evening on Christmas Eve. The worst time is mid-morning, because:

  • People are at work but leave early
  • Cars then clog strategic bus routes
  • Schools panic and request transport home, like, *now*, irrespective as to whether garages have vehicles or drivers in the right places
  • Buses increasingly get out of position and this compounds timetable chaos caused by an overloaded road network
  • Waiting passengers become exasperated
  • Revenue reduces sharply as costs increase, as passengers melt away and motorists offer lifts
  • Parts of the network become increasingly cut off by snow
With the internet and increasingly Twitter seemingly available just about everywhere these days, here are ideal media to get short messages out quickly. Though First recently abandoned its social media experiment in Bath, it is now using Twitter in the south west and in west Yorkshire. There were web snow bulletins from First Essex. Other operators use Facebook to get messages out quickly.


When First Group placed this Christmasy slide on its website, it could barely have considered the real consequences of this week's snow...

In a post on Tuesday, First Group’s Leon Daniels encapsulated things from an operations perspective, as follows:
“Whilst there is some merit in ‘pressing on’ through thick and thin at snail’s pace, and ‘getting through’, the truth is that your passengers have largely disappeared—preferring not to stay out in the awful conditions. If you are not careful, you end up with the fleet damaged and suffering from the effects of freezing up, and the staff exhausted. When the thaw comes and everyone wants to get back on your services to go to work or shopping, you are on your knees with too few serviceable buses and not enough staff.”
One other very noticeable side effect where services keep going is the grimy state of the buses themselves. All the Big Five take a pride in their vehicles’ appearances but this changes during exceptional conditions. Frozen garage water lines & bus washes plus road salt and slush gradually spread filth from behind the wheels to obscure windows. You’d think passengers would be forgiving but, in my experience, they tend to wonder why the bus side isn’t as clean as the windscreen.

It’s interesting that under these conditions various highways authorities usually get a roasting. Here, in the media’s mind, the bus service and winter salt spreading seem similarly aligned. Most authorities do an excellent job at keeping most strategic & bus routes open most of the time though, like bus operators, they cannot work miracles when the snow comes down faster than their teams can shift it, or when rain falls on already cold roads (salt treated or not), as seemed to happen in Cornwall on Tuesday, claiming the lives of two travellers on a Williams Travel, Camborne excursion.

Meanwhile, services were suspended in both Bournemouth & Southampton for a time on Wednesday, during one of the busiest days of the year. First pulled out, after four crashes. Transdev Yellow Buses did the same, following rain on frozen roads causing black ice, especially on untreated residential streets. Both parties were criticised for their safety efforts which, passengers claimed, caused distress for elderly and disabled passengers. In TYB's case, the decision to come off was at 0745 for about 40 minutes, well before most pensioners would be travelling, with free travel not due to kick in for some 1¾ hours.

7 comments:

dbg said...

I have to sat here in Plymouth both bus companies (First and Citybus) did a great job of keeping people up to date with the latest news. Both through Twitter and Citybus also on Facebook.

all in all a good effort all round.

Anonymous said...

Very impressed with the information that has been distributed locally during the disruption, I must say. Certainly Wilts and Dorset, Bluestar, Stagecoach South and Velvet have all been providing very timely and detailed updates through all sorts of different media, in ways that simply weren't posible or effective just a couple of years ago.

Now for round two this coming week... which in some areas might make round one look like a stroll in the park...

Anonymous said...

...and in contrast First deal with stuff so corporately! To defend cancelling services when others have tried so hard (in Southampton, First have publically said "we have not run in the interests of safety, unlike others" and "the police said we made the right decision" when they abandoned their customers). OK, you may have your reasons, but don't try to justify it with such arrogance - why would any customer ever congratulate you for doing so, whilst they do actually congratulate others for working so hard?!

Anonymous said...

"All the Big Five take a pride in their vehicles’ appearances" LOL, if you look at the state of First Glasgow's buses you wouldn't be saying that. Brand new Geminis are in a similar state to 20 year old buses. Admittedly a lot of people in Glasgow leave their rubbish on the bus and etch everywhere.

Anonymous said...

Anon at 1856. The difference being that First run on ungritted council estates more than any of the other operators in Southampton, and as Omnibuses had said, had already had four crashes before they decided to suspend services. How much harder do you want them to try?

The front page of the Daily Echo website has a shot of one of their buses across the road in the side of a car. Apparently, after this, a gritter lorry crashed into the bus, ruining its structure - a potential write off.

How else are they supposed to defend themselves. Nowadays, the public don't seem to think suspending services is acceptable even when there has been accidents.

God help us if we get to the stage where there has to have been several fatal crashes before the public "allow" services to be suspended.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous at 18:56, police telling an operator to suspend services is arrogance?

The black ice across virtually every Southampton street that morning was unprecedented leading to many not venturing past their own driveway. Those who did found virtually no buses running (most of Bluestars buses were parked up at the side of the road with drivers not knowing what to do despite what their website updates said!).

The BBC news showed images of a police van and at least one other car spinning round and round clearly out of control on one of the main arterial roads in Southampton and you expected buses to run?

All I can assume is that you didn't personally experience those horrendous weather conditions, if you did then you wouldn't make such crass comments.

Anonymous said...

BTW... I didn't see any public criticism of any operator who chose to suspend services? Certainly not in the local press or public comments left on websites which was on the whole understanding of the issues.